Vermont H 830: An act relating to the right of a student or parent or guardian to opt out of electronic device usage

Bill Text

BILL AS INTRODUCED H.830
2026 Page 1 of 4

VT LEG #386130 v.3
H.830 1
Introduced by Representatives Arsenault of Williston, Dobrovich of 2
Williamstown, Hunter of Manchester, Morgan, L. of Milton, 3
Taylor of Milton, and Torre of Moretown 4
Referred to Committee on 5
Date: 6
Subject: Education; courses of study; electronic devices 7
Statement of purpose of bill as introduced: This bill proposes to give students 8
or the parents or guardians of students in public schools and approved 9
independent schools the right to opt out of using electronic devices as part of 10
their education. It would also prohibit dismissing, suspending, disciplining, 11
reassigning, or transferring a teacher for choosing to teach a class or portions 12
of a class without the use of electronic devices. 13
An act relating to the right of a student or parent or guardian to opt out of 14
electronic device usage 15
It is hereby enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Vermont: 16
Sec. 1. FINDINGS 17
The General Assembly finds: 18
(1) In September 2025, the National Education Policy Center (NEPC) 19
reported that “research has not supported the common-sense presumption that 20

BILL AS INTRODUCED H.830
2026 Page 2 of 4

VT LEG #386130 v.3
digital approaches to schooling are better than non-digital alternatives. At the 1
broadest level, widespread computer use in education has been found to be 2
associated with lower student achievement.” 3
(2) The NEPC also warned of the harmful data collection practices 4
utilized by so-called “ed tech” products, explaining that “the same platform 5
that delivers curricular materials to students also harvests, for example, those 6
students’ usage patterns, performance data, and engagement metrics... often 7
without the knowledge or consent of students, families, or educators.” 8
(3) After initially mandating the widespread adoption of technology in 9
schools, and subsequently prompted by sharp declines in student achievement, 10
the Swedish government has invested millions of dollars to ensure that 11
students have more access to textbooks. The Swedish government also 12
amended national curriculum requirements to say that “only analog learning 13
tools, such as books, should be used for children under the age of two and that 14
potential use of non-analog learning tools should be greatly restricted for all 15
other children.” 16
(4) In a 2025 national survey conducted by The New York Times, 70 17
percent of teachers said that school-issued devices distract students from 18
learning and engagement in class, and a majority said students had “used them 19
to play games or watch videos unrelated to school.” 20

BILL AS INTRODUCED H.830
2026 Page 3 of 4

VT LEG #386130 v.3
(5) Vermont students’ reading test scores have declined significantly 1
since 2016, and currently sit at an all-time low. Also in 2016, the Agency of 2
Education reported a dramatic increase in one-to-one devices for students. In 3
fact, that year there were 85,000 computers for student use in Vermont schools, 4
which is more than the total number of students in Vermont schools. 5
Sec. 2. 16 V.S.A. § 914 is added to read: 6
§ 914. STUDENT AND PARENT OR GUARDIAN RIGHT OF REFUSAL; 7
ELECTRONIC DEVICE USAGE 8
(a) A student or parent or guardian of a student in a public elementary or 9
secondary school or an approved independent school shall have the right to 10
refuse to use an electronic device in order to perform work forming part of a 11
course of instruction. 12
(b) Each school district and approved independent school shall adopt and 13
implement policies regarding a student’s or parent’s or guardian’s right of 14
refusal under this section, which shall include: 15
(1) the process by which a student or parent or guardian may exercise 16
this right; 17
(2) alternative education methods through which a student exercising the 18
right under this section can learn and be assessed on material required by the 19
course; and 20

BILL AS INTRODUCED H.830
2026 Page 4 of 4

VT LEG #386130 v.3
(3) a statement that no student shall be discriminated against or 1
penalized for the decision to exercise the right of refusal afforded by this 2
section. 3
(c) A teacher employed by a public school or approved independent school 4
shall not be dismissed, suspended, disciplined, reassigned, or transferred for 5
choosing to teach a class or portions of a class without the use of electronic 6
devices. 7
Sec. 3. EFFECTIVE DATE 8
This act shall take effect on July 1, 2026. 9